Investors have plenty of choices on where to put their money, but they may underappreciate how important the choice of investment vehicle can be.
For example, some fund managers run an OEIC and investment trust version of a similar mandate, leaving investors to decide, not just what they want to invest in, but also how to get their exposure.
There are roughly 32 of these “sibling pairs” of investment trusts and funds available to UK investors that have been run by the same manager for at least a decade, according to recent research by the Association of Investment Companies (AIC).
The data found that, in terms of share price total return, the investment trust format generally triumphed, with some 88% of trusts outperforming their sibling fund over the past decade. Over shorter time frames, this fell to 83% and then 73%, according to the research.
Nick Britton, research director at the AIC, warned that investors shouldn’t take this to mean trusts will always outperform.
Indeed, among the trusts that faltered compared to their fund counterparts, the gap between Ben Rogoff’s Polar Capital Global Tech and Polar Capital Technology Trust stood out.
On the AIC’s shortlist, Polar Capital Technology Trust ranked as the best-performing strategy over all standard time frames; in the past decade it beat Pacific Horizon by more than 300 percentage points.
But in this case, the OEIC has consistently triumphed. Over the past decade, Rogoff’s open-ended fund has delivered investors a 962.8% total return.
Over five years, the open-ended Polar Capital Global Tech was ahead by 30 percentage points, more than 60 percentage points in the past three, and around 13 percentage points in the past 12 months.
See also: AIC: Tech dominates trust performance in H1 2026
It was hardly the only fund to outperform its competitor trust over standard time frames: Sat Duhra’s Janus Henderson Asian Dividend Income Unit Trust also outpaced Henderson Far East Income over all time frames, according to the AIC’s research.
“The gap comes down to the differing mandates, rather than the structure. Both funds follow the same investment approach, but Henderson Far East Income Limited’s (HFEL) income commitment produces a more income-focused portfolio,” a spokesperson told Portfolio Adviser.
By contrast, the unit trust only needs to yield above the benchmark, currently around 6%, which means it can own more lower-income tech stocks that have strongly contributed to returns.
“The longer-term numbers also need context. Before November 2023, the two funds were even less comparable,” the Janus Henderson team continued. “HFEL then revised its strategy to strike a better balance between income and growth, and the performance gap has narrowed considerably since.”
Meanwhile, over one, three and five years, some investors in Schroders’ UK strategies could have found themselves better off with an OEIC. According to the research, Schroder UK Mid 250, ran by Andy Brough, would have actually outperformed the closed-ended Schroder UK Mid Cap trust by as much as 19 percentage points over five years.
The AIC’s Britton said: “This research shouldn’t be taken to mean that investment trusts will always outperform, but it does suggest that long-term investors who ignore trusts may be missing out.”
Digging beneath these headline numbers, it becomes clear how much of a difference investors could find between sibling strategies.
For example, the BlackRock World Mining Trust, led by Evy Hambro and Olivia Markham, surged nearly 433.4% to the end of September on a 10-year basis. By comparison, the open-ended BFG World Mining D4 was up 268.9%, a gap of nearly 164 percentage points, the widest outperformance from an investment company.
Another standout performance from a trust relative to its OEIC over the past 10 years came from the Baillie Gifford range. The Pacific Horizon Trust rose 433.6% over the same period, while Baillie Gifford Pacific was up 317.1%, the second-largest outperformance by a trust over the period.
The trust has also outperformed over the past one and three years, although it had a much worse five-year record than its open-ended counterpart, which outperformed by around 26 percentage points.
Both have similar regional allocations, with China, Korea, Taiwan, India and Vietnam representing the top five regional allocations in both portfolios.
But due to the trust not being constrained by the 5/10/40 limitation of UCITS funds, it has much higher allocations to names like TSMC and Samsung Electronics than its sibling, which have performed spectacularly as part of the AI boom (14.3% in TSMC vs 10% in the open-ended fund, for example).
Even over five years when the results were less favourable, the correct trust could still deliver spectacular returns versus its open-ended counterpart, as seen by Chikara Japan Income and Growth (formerly CC Japan Income and Growth) beating its open-ended sibling by nearly 50 percentage points, the strongest outperformance in that time frame.
“Being able to gear is clearly helpful, as is the flexibility to invest in less liquid assets,” Britton added. “With investment trusts, managers can also pick their moment to buy and sell investments, which isn’t always possible with funds that have to follow investment flows.”
See also: The top-performing investment trusts staging the quickest recovery















